All posts by Cooperatively Yours

Altman: dogsuit settlement not final yet

Click image to enlarge.
Click image to enlarge.
After the New York Post reported last month that the U.S. Attorney and East River had reached an $85,000 settlement on the discrimination suit against the coop, cooperator Tommy Loeb wrote to board president Gary Altman to request a full accounting of this lawsuit and other lawsuits filed by the coop against pet owners.

After our annual meeting in December, Mr. Altman admitted that the coop’s legal fees related to dog litigation was $575,000 for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2014.

The line item for “legal & audit” expenses in the coop’s annual report has increased dramatically in the past three years as pet owners have been pursued — an increase of $1.2 million over the 2009-2011 baseline. The board of directors has reported that $195,000 has been recouped from our insurance provider, but the coop’s insurance saw a spike last year of $292,000, possibly in response to increased litigation.

Mr. Altman reported to Mr. Loeb this week that the settlement had not yet been finalized, and so a full accounting could not yet be delivered.

East River Park shoreline clean-up — May 9

sweep-flyer-2015If you enjoy the promenade along East River Park, you’ve undoubtedly seen the garbage that gets caught up in the small coves created along the path. It’s an eyesore — and unavoidable. But you can help clean up the park’s shoreline before summer gets rolling.

On Saturday, May 9, volunteers from NYC to Troy will be working to clean up New York’s riverfronts for the fourth annual Riverkeeper Sweep. To join the nearby effort, meet outside the East River Park Track at East 6th Street at 1:00 pm on 5/9. Cleanup will stretch up to 12th Street and down to Montgomery.

Sweep volunteers should wear sturdy shoes or boots, clothing that they can get dirty, and should bring a hat, sunscreen, a reusable water bottle, and snacks. Please bring work gloves if you have them. Volunteer activities are suitable for elementary-aged children with proper adult supervision.

Questions? Contact Riverkeeper at sweep@riverkeeper.org or site leader John Koblinsky at koblinsky@gmail.com.

Corlears Hook ’It’s My Park!‘ Day — Sunday, May 3

corlears signFriends of Corlears Hook Park is a neighborhood group picking up steam over the past year. With spring finally arriving (?!), volunteers will help clean and beautify the park.

Teams will be dispatched throughout the park on various projects that may include:

  • Cleaning and spreading new wood chips in the dog runs
  • Weeding, raking, and bagging leaves throughout the park
  • Bagging trash throughout the park
  • Painting the security barriers at the park entrance
  • Pruning and trimming existing plantings

All are welcome to come help for as much or as little time as they have available.

This is a family-friendly event and the following fun programming will be on site for all to enjoy:

  • Representatives from CityScience will be on hand for kinetic learning activities, building of a human suspension bridge, and short histories of East River bridges.
  • Girl Scout Senior Troop 3015 and Cadette Troop 3016 will be doing “Bubble Science” activities, providing a telescope to look across the river, have a “game station” and a “song spot” for the younger kids.
  • NYC Parks Play Mobile will be on site providing face painting, balloon art, and various games and activities.

If you are interested in helping to organize, please email FriendsofCorlears@gmail.com. Otherwise, please come out to help on May 3rd.

Update on East River storm surge protection

Thanks to cooperator Susan Levinson for attending last week’s community meeting and providing us with her notes for this post.

The federal government is responding to Sandy with a bag of cash that in the next few years will transform East River Park. The East Side Coastal Resiliency Project (ESCR) — or the Big U, or the Dryline — will reshape the landscape of the waterfront in order to stop any future storm surge from damaging property and casting lower Manhattan in darkness as happened in October 2012.

bridging-berm-r-800x0Last Thursday and Monday, two community forums were held to discuss the project. Representatives from the mayor’s office, the Parks Department, and the Department of Design and Construction gave presentations and answered questions (along with Cantonese, Mandarin, and Spanish interpreters).

The project area is 23rd Street to Montgomery and is intended to protect naturally low-lying areas of the East Village and Lower East Side, as well as, crucially, the Con Ed station at 14th. For areas west of Montgomery, similar plans are expected later this year, and Mayor de Blasio has announced that city funds will be made available to areas outside the ESCR.

The goal is to protect lower Manhattan from floods without walling the waterfront off from the city. Landscaped berms will be constructed between the East River Park playing fields and the FDR. Imagine rolling hills that complement the park but are tall enough to keep the river from spilling over during a storm. (Watch this concept video.)

Not every stretch of the waterfront has the width to accommodate a full berm, notably right around Con Ed. In some places a simpler flood wall will be built, and in others a deployable surge barrier can be installed, though a berm, it was explained, is the most effective protection.

Several studies of the area have already been completed, including tree inventory, bridge inspection, and underwater structural survey of the waterfront. A preliminary design is expected to be completed by October 2015. The goal is to begin construction by mid-2017 with construction lasting 2-4 years.

Memo: Check and Maintain Working Smoke Detectors

The weekend’s tragedy in Brooklyn prompted this reminder today from management:

TO: All Shareholders

FROM: Shulie Wollman

Due to a tragic weekend fire in Brooklyn, all East River and Hillman Housing residents are urged to maintain working smoke detectors in more than one location within your apartment. The importance of having working smoke detectors cannot be overemphasized.

If anyone requires assistance in either purchasing or installing a smoke detector, please telephone our maintenance office at 212-677-5744 to arrange a consultation or submit a maintenance ticket online at http://coopvillage.coop/maintenance.php.

Thank you for your active participation in this matter, which could save your life or the life of a fellow cooperator.

Coop pays out $85,000 to settle federal dogsuit

The New York Post reports this morning that a settlement has been reached in the federal lawsuit against East River Housing.

This dog is not allowed, but others are.
This dog is not allowed, but others are.
Two cooperators, Amy Eisenberg and Steven Gilbert, will be paid a total of $85,000 for legal fees and be allowed to keep their service pets. The third cooperator, Stephanie Aaron, has one year to find a new home for her dog or find a new place to live.

The federal suit was filed in December 2013 on behalf of these three cooperators who claimed that they were denied appropriate accommodation for their disabilities; the coop’s position had been that since cooperators had not sought approval for their service animals prior to obtaining the pets that they were in breach of their leases.

Dogsuits drag on and on while costs mount

The New York Law Journal reported earlier this month that a motion by East River to dismiss one of the three tenants on whose behalf the U.S. Attorney is suing the coop was denied in federal court. (The New York Journal requires a free registration to read their article.)

Furthermore, a motion by East River to challenge the government’s claim that the coop’s behavior toward these three cooperators establishes a “pattern and practice” was also denied.

Southern District Judge Edgardo Ramos issued a detailed 64-page ruling against East River’s motions, allowing the government’s case to continue without change.

legal expenses

Legal fees for the coop continue to mount as coop-initiated lawsuits against dog owners have increased and since the U.S. Attorney’s discrimination case against the coop was filed in December, 2013. The line item for legal and audit expenses has increased 462% over the past three years, costing the coop an additional $1.2 million. The board of directors revealed in their recent newsletter that $195,000 in legal fees has been recouped from our insurance carrier — though the coop’s insurance expenses also increased by $292,000 last year, the first substantial increase in at least five years, possibly related to our excess litigation.

Friends of Corlears Hook Park planning meeting: 3/18 at 6 pm

CHPFriends of Corlears Hook Park will be meeting this Wednesday to discuss various issues including leadership of the group moving forward, possible spring and summer programs, and an update on some of the behind-the-scenes work that has been occurring over the cold winter months.

Wednesday, March 18
6:00 p.m.
East River Fireboat House
(If you could follow Grand Street straight across the FDR, this is the building you’d hit right before the river. You’ll need to use the pedestrian bridge at Delancey or Corlears Hook to get there.)

If you are not able to make this meeting but are interested in being part of the leadership of the group and/or have some programming ideas and connections please email Michael Marino at friendsofcorlears@gmail.com.

Also, save the date: Sunday May 3, 10 a.m. – 1 p.m. — Spring Clean-up at Corlears Hook Park.

Dryline community meetings — March 19 & 23

Flyer_ESCR_MarchMtgs_EngSpanish

The Dryline — or Big U, or East Side Coastal Resiliency Project — will make a tremendous impact on our relationship with the East River.

If you have questions, or want to be involved in the planning, you can attend one of two upcoming public meetings:

Thursday, March 19

Bard High School
525 East Houston Street

Monday, March 23

Washington Irving High School
40 Irving Place

Both nights, doors open at 6:30 p.m.; presentation begins at 7:00 p.m.; engagement exercise and Q&A will follow.